PCF scenario modelling is a what-if run on an existing product carbon footprint: you change a material, a supplier's emission factor, an energy source or a transport mode and recompute. It is only useful if the scenario keeps the same boundary, allocation and data-quality rules as the baseline, and it is not a claim until the change is real and verified.
PCF Scenario Modelling: How to Test Material, Supplier and Transport Swaps Before You Commit
Learn how PCF scenario modelling tests material, supplier and transport swaps against an ISO 14067 baseline, when a scenario becomes a claim, and what to ask vendors.
Summary
Why now: on 4 November 2026, the European Parliament's Environment Committee voted to let carmakers earn up to 7.5 percentage points of their 2035 CO2 target from European low-carbon steel (electrive), and the EU's new green-claims rules have applied since 27 September 2026 (EUR-Lex). Material swaps now carry commercial weight, and so do the claims you make about them.
Procurement wants to know if a recycled resin or a lower-carbon steel is worth the premium. Your biggest customer wants a decarbonisation roadmap for the part you sell them. And your PCF lives in a spreadsheet that took months to build.
This is a request we hear from product teams across chemicals, automotive and food: let us test the swap before we commit. This guide covers how to do it without breaking comparability, where a scenario ends and a claim begins, and what to ask tool vendors.
What is PCF scenario modelling?
PCF scenario modelling (also called eco-design modelling or product carbon footprint simulation) means copying a calculated product footprint, changing inputs, and recomputing. The baseline stays untouched beside it.
Typical levers: BOM changes (substitute a material, change a quantity, add recycled content), supplier-specific emission factors (replace an industry average with a supplier's primary PCF), energy (grid or diesel to renewable electricity), transport (mode, distance, sourcing region) and process or site (yield, scrap, location).
How do I model the carbon impact of switching materials in a product?
Start from a baseline PCF that already breaks emissions down by BOM line, then change only the line you are testing and recompute the whole product. The answer you need is the finished product's footprint before and after, not just the component's.
- Find the hotspot first so you test swaps where they matter.
- Define the swap precisely: same function, same declared unit.
- Pick the right emission factor: supplier-specific if you have it, otherwise a database factor matching technology and geography.
- Recompute through every BOM level so a sub-assembly swap rolls up to the finished product.
- Record what changed: line, factor, source, author.
How do you keep scenario results comparable to the baseline?
Keep every methodological choice identical between baseline and scenario, and change only the lever you are testing. If the boundary, allocation or data rules move at the same time, the delta mixes your design change with an accounting change.
Three frameworks set the rules most of your customers will expect:
- ISO 14067:2018 sets principles, requirements and guidelines for quantifying and reporting a product carbon footprint, and covers climate change only (ISO).
- PACT Methodology v3.0 (WBCSD) defines PACT-conformant PCFs as cradle-to-gate, sets an allocation hierarchy (avoid allocation, then physical relationships, then economic value, then other relationships), and requires a primary data share to be reported with each PCF (WBCSD PACT v3.0 guide).
- TfS PCF Guideline V3.0 is the chemical sector's methodological reference for calculating PCFs; TfS and PACT publish a joint guide on the differences between the two (TfS). In automotive, the Catena-X PCF Rulebook sets a harmonised calculation method and the CX-0136 standard governs how PCF data is exchanged (Catena-X).
Avoiding apples to oranges
Baseline and scenario must share the following, and each has a common trap:
- System boundary: same life-cycle stages (for PACT, cradle-to-gate). Trap: the scenario adds a use phase or end-of-life credit the baseline lacks.
- Declared unit: same functional or declared unit. Trap: comparing per kg when the new material changes part weight.
- Allocation: same allocation method for co-products and recycled inputs. Trap: a recycled-content scenario switches method to make recycled look better.
- Emission factor sources: same database version, or a documented switch. Trap: a database update moves the baseline at the same time as the swap.
- Data quality: comparable data-quality ratings. Trap: a supplier primary factor (good quality) compared against a default (poor) without flagging it.
Under PACT v3.0, technological, geographical and temporal representativeness are each scored from 1 (best) to 5 (worst), and data-quality ratings are required by the end of 2027. If your scenario improves the footprint mostly because a better factor replaced a default, say so. That is a data improvement, not a design improvement.
For a deeper look at the cost side of getting baselines right at scale, see our analysis of the PCF software business case: Excel vs platform.
Why does recompute speed matter so much?
Because scenario modelling is iterative: three resins, two suppliers and two routes are already twelve runs. A slow recompute means modelling documents the sourcing decision instead of informing it. Scale matters too. Reckitt, for example, moved from 333 representative products to footprints for 25,000 products, with Quantis bringing decarbonisation expertise and CO2 AI the visualisation and simulation capabilities; the resulting initiatives are being evaluated for progressive implementation (Reckitt customer story). The complete guide on scaling product footprints covers how teams get there.
Can I make a low-carbon claim from a PCF scenario?
No. A scenario describes a product that does not exist yet. A claim must describe the product you actually sell, and since 27 September 2026, EU consumer law sets hard limits on how you phrase it.
Directive (EU) 2024/825 on empowering consumers for the green transition (often called ECGT or EmpCo) required Member States to apply its measures from 27 September 2026. Its Annex I adds new practices to the EU blacklist of unfair commercial practices, including:
- a generic environmental claim where the trader cannot demonstrate recognised excellent environmental performance relevant to the claim (point 4a);
- a claim about the entire product when it concerns only one aspect of it (point 4b);
- claiming, based on offsetting, that a product has a neutral, reduced or positive greenhouse gas impact (point 4c).
Claims about future environmental performance are also in scope: under Article 6(2)(d), they must be backed by commitments set out in a detailed and realistic implementation plan with measurable, time-bound targets, regularly verified by an independent third-party expert whose findings are made available to consumers.
ISO 14067 does not help you here: it explicitly places carbon offsetting and communication of the footprint outside its scope. It tells you how to calculate, not what you may say.
A workable rule: scenarios stay internal; once a change is implemented, recalculate the real PCF with actual supplier data and keep the audit trail; any claim is specific (product, stage, baseline year) and backed by that recalculation, never by the scenario.
The directive targets claims to consumers, but a B2B number your customer repeats on a pack becomes their claim, and they will ask you for the evidence.
Why does this matter more for automotive suppliers right now?
Because steel and other material choices may soon count directly towards carmakers' regulatory targets. The Environment Committee text, adopted 48 to 30 with two abstentions, sets a 95% cut in new-car CO2 emissions by 2035 versus 2021, with up to 7.5 further percentage points available for using climate-friendly steel produced in Europe, so the effective floor could fall to 87.5%. This is a committee position: the plenary vote is scheduled for December and the Council must still act.
If the text survives, suppliers who can show OEMs a steel-swap scenario on their own BOM will be ahead in those conversations.
What should a PCF simulation tool do? An evaluation checklist
Ask each vendor to run these tests on one of your own products, not a demo dataset.
- Recompute speed: scenario results in seconds or minutes, not days. Ask: "Change three BOM lines on my product and show me the new total now."
- BOM depth: edit materials at any level, with changes rolling up to the finished product. Ask: "Swap a material two levels down. Where do I see the finished-product delta?"
- Lever coverage: materials, quantities, energy, transport, production stages. Ask: "Replace diesel with renewable electricity in production. Can I?"
- Supplier EF swap: replace a database factor with a supplier primary PCF, per row or for all rows using that factor. Ask: "Apply this supplier's PCF to one row only, then to all rows."
- Methodology lock: the scenario inherits baseline boundary, allocation and factor database. Ask: "What stops a user changing allocation inside a scenario?"
- Data quality visibility: DQR and primary data share shown for baseline and scenario. Ask: "Show me how data quality changed, not just the number."
- Audit trail: every change logged with who, when, what, and source. Ask: "Show me the log an auditor would see."
- Export and exchange: PACT and TfS-aligned outputs, API sharing. Ask: "Export the scenario and the baseline side by side."
- Claim guardrails: clear separation of scenarios from published PCFs. Ask: "Can a scenario ever overwrite the official footprint?"
How CO2 AI approaches scenario modelling
CO2 AI, an AI-powered carbon management platform used by enterprises such as Volvo Group, Reckitt and Pernod Ricard, builds product footprints at scale and lets teams test changes on them. Its Eco-design module lets you compare materials, suppliers and manufacturing processes side by side, connects to BOM and PLM data, logs each design decision for traceability, and shares PCFs with customers and partners via API. The platform states that footprints are compliant with PACT, TfS, ISO 14067 and ISO 14044.
The honest trade-off: any platform is only as good as the baseline underneath. If your BOMs are incomplete or your factors mostly defaults, fix that first.

See the Platform in Action
Test material, supplier and transport swaps on your own BOMs, against a PACT and TfS-aligned baseline, and see the finished-product result in one view.
Discover other insights

From Annual Footprint to Decarbonisation Trajectory: How to Build a Realistic Marginal Abatement Cost Curve for Your CSRD Transition Plan
.jpg)
Catena-X PCF Exchange Across Five Supply Chain Levels: What the First Multi-Tier Pilot Means for Your Supplier Data
.jpg)

What would you like to read next?