A marginal abatement cost curve (MACC) ranks your decarbonisation levers by cost per tonne of CO2e avoided and by volume. To make it credible for a CSRD transition plan, build it lever by lever from your measured footprint, let costs rise with volume and region, model scenarios over time, and tie the result to your targets and ESRS E1-1 disclosures.
From Annual Footprint to Decarbonisation Trajectory: How to Build a Realistic Marginal Abatement Cost Curve for Your CSRD Transition Plan
Turn your annual footprint into a decarbonisation trajectory: build a marginal abatement cost curve that rises with volume and meets ESRS E1 transition plan rules.

Summary
Why now: the simplified ESRS, Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/1563, entered into force on 10 November 2026 and applies to financial years starting on or after 1 January 2027. The climate transition plan, with its decarbonisation levers and funding, remains at the heart of ESRS E1.
Your footprint is closed, audited and signed off. Then the CFO asks the obvious next question: "So what does it cost to hit the 2030 target, and in what order do we spend?"
Most sustainability teams answer with an annual snapshot and an Excel action plan. It works until someone in finance spots that every lever carries the same average cost per tonne, or that abating the last 20% of emissions apparently costs the same as the first 20%. At that point the plan loses credibility, and so does the team presenting it.
A common question from sustainability teams we speak with is exactly this: how do you turn a yearly footprint into a decarbonisation trajectory, with scenarios and a marginal abatement cost curve that finance will actually believe? This guide walks through it.
What is a marginal abatement cost curve?
A marginal abatement cost curve is a chart that lists each emission reduction lever by its cost per tonne of CO2e abated (vertical axis) and the volume of emissions it can remove (horizontal axis). Levers are sorted from cheapest to most expensive, so you can see which actions pay for themselves and where costs climb.
The abatement cost per tonne for a lever is, in simple terms, its net cost over its lifetime (capex and opex, minus savings) divided by the tonnes it avoids over the same period. Levers below zero save money; levers above zero need a budget or a carbon price to make sense.
For a Head of Sustainability, the MACC answers "what should we do first?". For a CFO, it answers "how much will this cost, and when?". That shared view is why it has become the default language for transition plans.
Why do flat-average MACCs fail with finance teams?
They fail because they assume that every tonne abated by a lever costs the same, wherever and whenever you abate it. Reality does not work that way.
The academic literature has warned about this for over a decade. In Climate Policy (2012), Fabian Kesicki and Paul Ekins argue that MAC curves should be one decision tool among several, because they exclude intertemporal dynamics, handle uncertainty poorly and, when built measure by measure, can ignore interactions between measures, non-financial costs and inconsistent baselines. Economist Stéphane Hallegatte makes a similar point in an I4CE interview: the cost and reduction of each option depend on which other options are implemented, and the curves usually assume that cost does not depend on how fast you deploy.
In practice, three effects push the cost per tonne up as you go further:
- Volume. The first 10% of renewable electricity, recycled content or supplier engagement is cheap. The next tranche needs new contracts, new suppliers or new assets, and costs rise.
- Region. The same lever has a different cost in markets with different grid mixes, energy prices, subsidies and supplier maturity.
- Interdependency. Once you switch to renewable electricity, an efficiency project abates fewer tonnes, so its cost per tonne goes up. Count both at full value and you double count.
When a pilot shows very deep abatement at a single flat average cost per tonne, experienced finance and operations teams tend to reject it as unrealistic. They are right to.
Flat-average MACC vs realistic MACC
- Cost per tonne: a flat-average MACC uses one average per lever; a realistic MACC rises in tranches as volume increases.
- Geography: flat uses a global average; realistic varies by region, site or sourcing market.
- Interactions: flat adds levers independently; realistic sequences them and removes overlaps to avoid double counting.
- Time: flat is static, one year; realistic runs year by year, with deployment speed and cost evolution.
- Baseline: flat uses last year's footprint; realistic uses a business-as-usual projection (growth, mix, grid).
- Uncertainty: flat gives a single point; realistic gives ranges or scenarios (low, central, high).
- Ownership: flat is a sustainability team spreadsheet; realistic has levers owned by operations, procurement and finance.
- Use in CSRD: flat is hard to defend in E1-1; realistic feeds levers, actions, funding and assumptions.
What does ESRS E1 require in a climate transition plan?
Under the simplified ESRS, Disclosure Requirement E1-1 asks you to disclose your transition plan for climate change mitigation, or to say clearly that you do not have one. According to the EFRAG Knowledge Hub text of the delegated act, paragraph 12 covers:
- Key features: GHG emission reduction targets, decarbonisation levers, key actions, the investments and funding required, approval by the administrative, management and supervisory bodies, and how the plan is embedded in overall strategy. You also explain how your strategy and business model are, or will be, compatible with limiting warming to 1.5°C and with the EU's 2050 climate neutrality objective.
- CapEx related to coal, oil and gas activities, where relevant.
- Key assumptions and dependencies the plan relies on.
- Locked-in emissions: a qualitative assessment of how emissions locked in by key assets and products could jeopardise the plan.
- Progress in implementing the plan.
If you have no plan with those key features, paragraph 13 requires you to say so and state whether, and when, you expect to adopt one.
Two application requirements matter directly for your MACC. AR 2 asks you to identify decarbonisation levers and to disclose significant financial resources allocated or expected, with an indicative range, while noting that detailed internal management information is not required. AR 5 asks you to report progress in terms of resources deployed, actions taken and GHG reductions achieved or expected.
The takeaway: you do not publish your MACC. But a realistic MACC is the cleanest way to produce the levers, funding ranges and assumptions E1-1 expects, and to defend them to your auditor and board.
Timing matters too. The revised standards apply to financial years beginning on or after 1 January 2027, and for FY2026 companies already in scope can choose which version to apply, stating which one they used. If your FY2027 plan needs a credible trajectory, the modelling work starts now.
How do you turn a carbon footprint into a decarbonisation trajectory? 7 steps
1. Start from a granular, trusted baseline
Your trajectory is only as good as the footprint underneath it. You need emissions broken down by the dimensions your levers act on: site, energy source, supplier, material, product, region. A total by scope is not enough to model a lever. This is where a robust corporate footprint pays off.
2. Project a business-as-usual baseline
Emissions will move without any action: volumes grow, the product mix shifts, grids decarbonise. Model that path year by year to your target year. Your levers are measured against this projection, not against last year's number.
3. Build a lever library with owners
List levers per scope: renewable electricity, electrification of heat, logistics mode shift, recycled content, recipe or formulation changes, supplier-specific emission factors, supplier engagement programmes. For each, name an operational owner. Levers without an owner rarely survive the budget round.
4. Cost each lever in tranches, by region
Instead of one average cost, define cost per tonne in steps: first tranche, second tranche, ceiling. Split by region or sourcing market where costs differ. Combine capex, opex and savings, and agree the assumptions (energy prices, discount rate, carbon price) with finance before you start.
5. Sequence levers and remove overlaps
Apply levers in a logical order and recalculate the remaining emissions after each one, so that two levers never claim the same tonne. This is the step most spreadsheets skip, and the one that most often inflates abatement.
6. Run scenarios over time
Build at least three scenarios (for example: approved projects only, central plan, accelerated plan) and model each one year by year, including deployment speed. Each scenario gives you a trajectory, a cumulative cost and a residual gap to target.
7. Check against targets and lock it into governance
Compare each trajectory with your targets. If you work with the Science Based Targets initiative, its Corporate Near-Term Criteria V5.3.1 (April 2026) require near-term targets covering 5 to 10 years, at least 95% of Scope 1 and 2 emissions, and, where relevant Scope 3 is 40% or more of total emissions, at least 67% of Scope 3. Then get the chosen scenario approved, track progress against it each year, and you have the material for E1-1 progress reporting.
Want to see what lever-based scenario modelling looks like on a real footprint? Explore CO2 AI decarbonisation.
How do you build a MACC that covers Scope 3?
The same method applies, but the data changes. Scope 3 levers act on suppliers, materials and products, so you need supplier-level or product-level emissions to size them. Without that granularity, a "switch to low-carbon packaging" lever is a guess.
Practical tips:
- Model supplier levers at the level where the decision is made: a supplier, a material category, a sourcing region.
- Reflect that supplier engagement costs and outcomes vary by supplier maturity, so the cost per tonne rises as you move down the supplier list.
- Link product-level changes (formulation, packaging, sourcing) to purchase volumes, so the lever scales with the business.
In practice: roadmaps that teams can actually use
Pernod Ricard visualises its decarbonisation roadmap in CO2 AI based on targets and business forecasts. Teams can simulate and compare the impact of newly suggested initiatives before adding them to the roadmap, and progress can be tracked at team and Group level. Our solution allows you to model different scenarios to meet your targets on top of your measured footprint, at corporate and product level.
Why does the CFO need to own the curve too?
Because a transition plan is a capital allocation plan. E1-1 asks for investments, funding and an indicative range of financial resources, which is finance's territory.
As discussed in our CFO webinar recap, finance leaders want a defensible number they can take to the audit committee. A MACC built with finance's own assumptions (prices, discount rate, volumes) is far easier to defend than one built in isolation. See how finance teams use CO2 AI.
The pressure is also rising outside CSRD. In the EU ETS reform debate, more than 100 European industrial companies have reportedly objected to allocating free allowances only to businesses that pledge decarbonisation investment in Europe, with the European Parliament due to vote on the reform in December. Whatever the outcome, decarbonisation plans are becoming financial documents.

See the Platform in Action
See how CO2 AI turns your measured footprint into lever-based roadmaps and scenarios your finance team can defend.
Discover other insights
PCF Scenario Modelling: How to Test Material, Supplier and Transport Swaps Before You Commit
.jpg)
Catena-X PCF Exchange Across Five Supply Chain Levels: What the First Multi-Tier Pilot Means for Your Supplier Data
.jpg)

What would you like to read next?